Talk:April Fool's Day 2005/Featured article candidate: Difference between revisions
From Bulbapedia, the community-driven Pokémon encyclopedia.
⧼bulbapediamonobook-jumptonavigation⧽⧼bulbapediamonobook-jumptosearch⧽
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
* I agree with the previous comment. In addition, it may be wise to have another candidate ready, as this article will only be relevant for a few weeks at the most. - [[User:Argy|Argy]] 01:07, 4 Apr 2005 (UTC) | * I agree with the previous comment. In addition, it may be wise to have another candidate ready, as this article will only be relevant for a few weeks at the most. - [[User:Argy|Argy]] 01:07, 4 Apr 2005 (UTC) | ||
===Object ( | ===Object (2)=== | ||
* The article seems to have very limited relevance now that the day had passed, and is in all honesty little more than a list of events, with little depth. Hardly the kind of material we'd want for our first feature. - [[User:Archaic]] | * The article seems to have very limited relevance now that the day had passed, and is in all honesty little more than a list of events, with little depth. Hardly the kind of material we'd want for our first feature. - [[User:Archaic]] | ||
Revision as of 16:13, 5 April 2005
Support (2)
- A unique report that is informative and well illustrated. - 振霖T 17:39, 3 Apr 2005 (UTC)
- I agree with the previous comment. In addition, it may be wise to have another candidate ready, as this article will only be relevant for a few weeks at the most. - Argy 01:07, 4 Apr 2005 (UTC)
Object (2)
- The article seems to have very limited relevance now that the day had passed, and is in all honesty little more than a list of events, with little depth. Hardly the kind of material we'd want for our first feature. - User:Archaic
- Agreed. The first impression that people get from coming to Bulbapedia could very well be the featured article, being the cream of the crop, if this is a page of jokes... Then well I don't think it's a good advertisement if anything else. And while it is informative, it has little content at all, being nothing more of a basic list and a couple of screenshots. Little effort has been put into the article. - Ferret
Other comments
- A reminder: the featured article of the day is different from a featured article - an article will always have featured article status, and a featured article of the day is necessarily a featured article; however, a featured article does not necessarily have to ever be, or have been a featured article of the day. - 振霖T 16:05, 5 Apr 2005 (UTC)
