Talk:History of Poké Balls: Difference between revisions
m Fixed unsigned comment. |
Force Fire (talk | contribs) Undo revision 3331562 by Elementcollector1 (talk)Do not re-sign an unsigned comment |
||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
I'm also unsure of the canonicity of Prof. Westwood developing the modern models in 1925, as this appears to come from the Pokemon Daisuki Club's Encyclopedia Pokemonica, which is (as far as I'm aware) a *fan* work. Westwood also appears in the anime and may or may not have created/programmed/written for the Pokedex, but I fail to see why this shouldn't be marked as potentially non-canon. | I'm also unsure of the canonicity of Prof. Westwood developing the modern models in 1925, as this appears to come from the Pokemon Daisuki Club's Encyclopedia Pokemonica, which is (as far as I'm aware) a *fan* work. Westwood also appears in the anime and may or may not have created/programmed/written for the Pokedex, but I fail to see why this shouldn't be marked as potentially non-canon. | ||
The reason I bring this up is because of Pokemon Legends: Arceus - with the new wooden Poke Balls, it seems like a more comprehensive history of Poke Balls in the games should be considered rather than accepting fanon and anime canon. | The reason I bring this up is because of Pokemon Legends: Arceus - with the new wooden Poke Balls, it seems like a more comprehensive history of Poke Balls in the games should be considered rather than accepting fanon and anime canon. {{unsigned|Elementcollector1}} | ||
Revision as of 05:15, 27 February 2021
Don't you think...
...that we should mention in the article that this History is only canon to the Anime continuity? - Ericss 01:50, 15 January 2012 (UTC)
Timeline for just poketechnology
I'm not sure what order this is presented in... possible the order the episodes aired in? If we can get exact quotes ("centuries ago" v "thousands of years ago", etc.) I think we might be able to put this into some rough order. I'll have a go at that... ty (talk) 18:44, 30 May 2019 (UTC)
So about that '400 - 700 years' thing...
That was, to the best of my knowledge from the Apricorn page's history (first submission), determined by cross-referencing the time of the Brass Tower burning (700 ya) and the first Orange League competitions (400 ya), and has no basis in the core games - so shouldn't that be marked somehow?
I'm also unsure of the canonicity of Prof. Westwood developing the modern models in 1925, as this appears to come from the Pokemon Daisuki Club's Encyclopedia Pokemonica, which is (as far as I'm aware) a *fan* work. Westwood also appears in the anime and may or may not have created/programmed/written for the Pokedex, but I fail to see why this shouldn't be marked as potentially non-canon.
The reason I bring this up is because of Pokemon Legends: Arceus - with the new wooden Poke Balls, it seems like a more comprehensive history of Poke Balls in the games should be considered rather than accepting fanon and anime canon. - unsigned comment from Elementcollector1 (talk • contribs)
