Talk:M11: Difference between revisions
LostDrewid (talk | contribs) (→"Megaliba": new section) |
LostDrewid (talk | contribs) m (→"Megaliba") |
||
| Line 24: | Line 24: | ||
For starters, it seems to be a superfluous page - it's a ship belonging to a character in this movie. To me, it does not seem to be Notable enough to have its own page. Yes, notability as defined by site policy only requires it to be part of canon, which it is - but there's so little information about it that it is a waste to have on its own page. Instead, that information could enhance [[Zero|its owner's]] page, making that article more complete. | For starters, it seems to be a superfluous page - it's a ship belonging to a character in this movie. To me, it does not seem to be Notable enough to have its own page. Yes, notability as defined by site policy only requires it to be part of canon, which it is - but there's so little information about it that it is a waste to have on its own page. Instead, that information could enhance [[Zero|its owner's]] page, making that article more complete. | ||
If people more knowledgeable than I deem it notable enough for its own page, I would at least suggest a page move: Megaliba is a poor transliteration at ''best''. The article says the ship is sometimes called the Mega Reverse; I could get into the technicalities of the Japanese language, but I already did so on [[Talk:Megaliba|Megaliba's talk page]]. Suffice it to say, "liba" is supposed to be an abbreviation of Reverse, which makes no sense when seen in English alone; in Japanese, it's リバ and リバース, respectively. I would highly recommend moving the page to "Mega Reverse" and updating any page that links to Megaliba. In all technicality I could do so myself, but as a relatively inactive member, I don't particularly want to ruffle any feathers. [[User:LostDrewid|LostDrewid]] 03:20, 23 November 2008 (UTC) | If people more knowledgeable than I deem it notable enough for its own page, I would at least suggest a page move: Megaliba is a poor transliteration at ''best''. The article says the ship is sometimes called the Mega Reverse; I could get into the technicalities of the Japanese language, but I already did so on [[Talk:Megaliba|Megaliba's talk page]]. Suffice it to say, "liba" is supposed to be an abbreviation of Reverse, which makes no sense when seen in English alone; in Japanese, it's リバ and リバース, respectively. I would highly recommend moving the page to "[[Mega Reverse]]" and updating any page that links to [[Megaliba]]. In all technicality I could do so myself, but as a relatively inactive member, I don't particularly want to ruffle any feathers. [[User:LostDrewid|LostDrewid]] 03:20, 23 November 2008 (UTC) | ||
Revision as of 03:22, 23 November 2008
Archives
"Giratina and the Sky Warrior"
Why did the name get changed to that? It was unconfirmed news! Unconfirmed! SharKing ((Talk to the King!)) 03:03, 11 November 2008 (UTC)
- I'll ask Jonouchi which source he used to justify the move. If he names a voice actor's blog, the page gets moved back and the ensuing redirect deleted. --Shiningpikablu252 03:09, 11 November 2008 (UTC)
- According to Sarah Natochenny's official website this is the US title of the film Livinlarge18 22:13, 20 November 2008 (UTC)
- A voice actor's website is not a reliable source by any stretch of the imagination when it comes to titles of episodes or movies. Honestly, if we were to have believed that website, then DP108 and DP109 would be bluelinked based solely on that Japanese actor's blog. Trust me, blogs and websites of voice actors could give misleading titles, and we're to assume such titles are misleading unless proven otherwise. --Shiningpikablu252 22:35, 20 November 2008 (UTC)
- Why the frick would Sarah lie she wasn't lying about playing Staravia,Roselia,Staraptor,Delia or Johanna Livinlarge18 22:39, 20 November 2008 (UTC)
- According to Sarah Natochenny's official website this is the US title of the film Livinlarge18 22:13, 20 November 2008 (UTC)
It's not unconfirmed anymore. Check www.pokemon.com --PikamasterADV 02:03, 22 November 2008 (UTC)
- I don't think so, Sometime it can be false, but... What the heck [[1]]
- --Force Fire 02:15, 22 November 2008 (UTC)
- OMG that poster is incredible =D I'm so happy --Nick., something to say? 02:21, 22 November 2008 (UTC)
"Megaliba"
I have questions regarding this page, but I am a largely inactive member of the Bulbapedia community and do not know the best place to raise such questions; the page's talkpage is likely not to see very much activity, so I thought it best to bring my question here. Forgive me if this was not the best decision.
For starters, it seems to be a superfluous page - it's a ship belonging to a character in this movie. To me, it does not seem to be Notable enough to have its own page. Yes, notability as defined by site policy only requires it to be part of canon, which it is - but there's so little information about it that it is a waste to have on its own page. Instead, that information could enhance its owner's page, making that article more complete.
If people more knowledgeable than I deem it notable enough for its own page, I would at least suggest a page move: Megaliba is a poor transliteration at best. The article says the ship is sometimes called the Mega Reverse; I could get into the technicalities of the Japanese language, but I already did so on Megaliba's talk page. Suffice it to say, "liba" is supposed to be an abbreviation of Reverse, which makes no sense when seen in English alone; in Japanese, it's リバ and リバース, respectively. I would highly recommend moving the page to "Mega Reverse" and updating any page that links to Megaliba. In all technicality I could do so myself, but as a relatively inactive member, I don't particularly want to ruffle any feathers. LostDrewid 03:20, 23 November 2008 (UTC)
