User:Amiosi/List of design discrepancies

From Bulbapedia, the community-driven Pokémon encyclopedia.
< User:Amiosi
Revision as of 21:44, 17 April 2024 by Amiosi (talk | contribs) (stopping point)
Jump to navigationJump to search
Bulbapedia bulb.png This article is intended to be moved into one of Bulbapedia's main content spaces.
Be mindful that it is still part of a personal userspace. Any content changes should be brought up on the talk page for this article.

Throughout the franchise, the design of some Pokémon received various amounts of changes. Some were temporary, only lasting for one or two games, while others remained for a fair bit longer, causing a disconnect between the video games and other Pokémon-related media.

Overview

The first few generations are interesting due to the sprites having been made before the artwork[1], rendering the "errors" and other oddities as nothing more than design revisions.

Generation I, for instance, had the original designs tweaked in some places, with Pokémon Blue giving the original roster new sprites, though the back sprites were consistently left untouched. Pokémon Yellow would later update the front sprites once more, this time explicitly basing them after the Pokémon's appearance in the animated series.

In Pokémon Gold and Silver, the sprites for the Kanto Pokémon are mainly based on the contemporary Red and Blue artwork, with some of the new elements tentatively introduced there (such as Nidoqueen's fangs) making a return. Much like with Yellow, Pokémon Crystal later changed a good handful of sprites, using each Pokémon's respective artwork as a basis. This mostly affected the Johto Pokémon, and this time around the back sprites were also updated here and there.

Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire is likely when the artwork was starting to be drawn before the sprites, leaving most of the inconsistencies to be minor in comparison to previous generations. However, many of the Generation I and II Pokémon were either copied directly from Crystal, or based on Red and Green or Red and Blue artwork, as those Pokémon had yet to be redrawn for FireRed and LeafGreen or HeartGold and SoulSilver.

List of sprite discrepancies

Sprite discrepancies due to design revisions

Generation I Pokémon

No. Pokémon Game(s) Reason
001 Spr 1g 001.pngSpr 1b 001.pngSpr b g1 001.png Bulbasaur Generation I core series Originally had round ears instead of triangular ones.
002 Spr 1g 002.pngSpr 1b 002.pngSpr b g1 002.png
Spr 2g 002.pngSpr 2s 002.pngSpr 2c 002.png
Pin002.png
Ivysaur Generation I core series
Generation II core series
Pokémon Pinball
Originally had a stalk, round ears instead of triangular ones, and two leaves instead of four. Red and Blue changed the ears, while Generation II changed the leaf count on the back sprites only. The Generation I back sprite features a tail, while the Red and Blue front sprite depicts it as bipedal.
003 Spr 1g 003.pngSpr 1b 003.pngSpr b g1 003.png
Spr 2g 003.pngSpr 2c 003.pngSpr b 2g 003.pngSpr b 2c 003.png
Spr 3r 003.pngSpr 3f 003.pngSpr 3e 003.png
Spr b 3r 003.pngSpr b 3f 003.png
Venusaur Generation I core series
Generation II core series
Generation III core series
Originally had spots, round ears instead of triangular ones, two leaves instead of four, and five petals instead of six. Red and Blue changed the ears and leaf count, while Yellow removed the spots and changed the petal count. The petal count was not carried forward after this, however, as it only appeared on the Silver front sprite before Generation IV. The Generation I back sprite features a tail, while the Generation II, Ruby, Sapphire, and Emerald back sprites feature a rounder petal shape. The five-petal design was reflected in its Red and Blue artwork.
004 Spr 1g 004.pngSpr b g1 004.png Charmander Generation I core series Originally had a dorsal ridge. This was reflected in its Carddass artwork.
005 Spr 1g 005.pngSpr b g1 005.png Charmeleon Generation I core series Originally had a horn instead of a head protrusion.
007 Spr 1g 007.pngSpr 1b 007.pngSpr b g1 007.png Squirtle Generation I core series Originally had a different plastron design, cheek patterns, and a fluffier tail resembling Wartortle's.
009 Spr 1g 009.pngSpr 1b 009.pngSpr 1y 009.pngSpr b g1 009.png
Spr 2g 009.pngSpr 2s 009.pngSpr 2c 009.pngSpr b 2g 009.png
Spr 3r 009.pngSpr 3f 009.pngSpr 3e 009.pngSpr b 3r 009.png
Pin009.png
Blastoise Generation I core series
Generation II core series
Generation III core series
Pokémon Pinball
Originally had different cannon cover designs. It was first changed in Yellow, and then to its current design FireRed and LeafGreen, though only on the back sprite.
010 Spr 1g 010.pngSpr 1b 010.pngSpr b g1 010.png
Pin010.png
Caterpie Generation I core series
Pokémon Pinball
Originally lacked the pattern on its body.
011 Spr 1g 011.pngSpr b g1 011.png Metapod Generation I core series Originally had crosshair-shaped eyes instead of droopy ones.
012 Spr 1g 012.pngSpr b g1 012.png Butterfree Generation I core series Originally had differently shaped wings.
014 Spr 1g 014.pngSpr 1b 014.pngSpr b g1 014.png Kakuna Generation I core series Originally lacked pupils. The Red and Blue sprite has its pincers extended, as seen in its Carddass artwork.
016 Pinani016.png Pidgey Pokémon Pinball Features much longer eyebrows, as seen in its Red and Blue artwork.
019 Spr 1g 019.pngSpr b g1 019.png Rattata Generation I core series Originally had a white tail.
020 Spr 1g 020.pngSpr 1b 020.png
Spr 3r 020.pngSpr 3e 020.png
Raticate Generation I core series
Ruby and Sapphire
Emerald
Originally had four fingers on each hand instead of three. This was changed in Yellow, but returned in Ruby, Sapphire, and Emerald.
022 Spr 1g 022.pngSpr 1b 022.pngSpr 1y 022.png Fearow Generation I core series Originally had three talons instead of four.
024 Spr b g1 024.png Arbok Generation I core series Originally had wave-shaped markings on its back.
025 Spr 1g 025.pngSpr 1b 025.png Arbok Generation I core series Originally had a white belly. This was reflected in its Carddass artwork.
029 Spr b g1 029.pngPin029.png Nidoran♀ Generation I core series
Pokémon Pinball
The Generation I back sprite features different spike placement. Pinball features a tail, as seen in its Red and Blue artwork.
030 Spr b g1 030.png Nidorina Generation I core series The back sprite depicts it as lacking spikes altogether.
031 Spr 1g 031.pngSpr b g1 031.png
Spr 2g 031.pngSpr 2c 031.png
Spr 3r 031.pngSpr 3f 031.pngSpr 3e 031.png
Nidoqueen Generation I core series
Gold
Crystal
Generation III core series
Originally had two rows of spikes. The Generation II and III front sprites feature fangs, as seen in its Red and Blue artwork.
033 Spr 1g 033.pngSpr 1b 033.pngSpr b g1 033.png Nidorino Generation I core series Originally had a tail, as well as a line running through the its inner ear. The back sprite features a dorsal ridge.
034 Spr 1g 034.pngSpr b g1 034.png Nidoking Generation I core series Originally had two toes on each foot. The back sprite features two rows of spikes.
035 Spr 1g 035.pngSpr 1b 035.pngSpr b g1 035.png
Spr 2g 035.pngSpr 2s 035.png
Clefairy Generation I core series
Gold and Silver
Originally had pawpads, a different ear shape, and a dorsal ridge. Red and Blue changed the ear shape and changed the dorsal ridge to wings, while Crystal removed the pawpads.
036 Spr b g1 036.png
Spr b 3r 036.pngSpr b 3f 036.png
Spr b 4d 036.pngSpr b 4p 036.png
Clefable Generation I core series
Generation III core series
Generation IV core series
The Generation I back sprite features a different ear shape. The Generation III and IV back sprites feature a heart-shaped pattern on its wings.
037 Spr 1g 037.pngSpr 1b 037.pngSpr b g1 037.png Vulpix Generation I core series Originally had different crest designs. The back sprite features a completely different design, while the Red, Green, and Blue front sprite resembles the current one, albeit with two curls instead of three.
038 Spr 1g 038.pngSpr b g1 038.png
Spr 3r 038.pngSpr 3f 038.pngSpr 3e 038.png
Ninetales Generation I core series
Generation III core series
Originally had a different crest design. The Generation III front sprites lack differently-colored tail tips, as seen in its Red and Blue artwork.
040 Spr 1g 040.pngSpr 1b 040.pngSpr b g1 040.png
Spr 2g 040.pngSpr 2c 040.png
Spr 3r 040.pngSpr 3e 040.pngSpr b 3r 040.png
Pin040.png
Wigglytuff Generation I core series
Gold
Crystal
Ruby and Sapphire
Emerald
Pokémon Pinball
Originally had a white hair tuft instead of a pink one, as well as a stomach pattern that doesn't reach over the mouth. The Generation I back sprite and Red and Blue front sprite have pink eartips. Red and Blue changed the stomach pattern, while Yellow changed the hair tuft and eartips. Some of these traits returned in both Generation II and III.
042 Spr 1b 042.png Golbat Red and Blue Features a long tongue only ever seen again in spin-off games.
045 Spr b g1 045.png Vileplume Generation I core series The back sprite lacks white spots.
049 Spr 1g 049.pngSpr 1b 049.pngSpr b g1 049.png Venomoth Generation I core series Originally had a different wing pattern, triangular pupils, and lacked mandibles.
052 Spr b g1 052.png Meowth Generation I core series The backs of its ears were originally black instead of cream.
053 Spr 1g 053.pngSpr 1b 053.pngSpr b g1 053.png Persian Generation I core series Originally had dark paw and tail accents, and the backs of its ears were black instead of cream.
055 Spr 1g 055.pngSpr 1b 055.png Golduck Red and Green
Red and Blue
Originally had four fingers on each hand instead of three. This was reflected in its Red and Blue artwork.
056 Spr 1g 056.pngSpr 1b 056.pngSpr b g1 056.png Mankey Generation I core series Originally lacked dark paws and had a white tail tip.
061 Spr 1g 061.pngSpr 1b 061.png
Spr 2g 061.pngSpr 2s 061.pngSpr 2c 061.png
Spr b 2g 061.pngSpr b 2c 061.png
Spr 3r 061.pngSpr b 3r 061.png
Pin061.png
Poliwhirl Red and Green
Red and Blue
Generation II core series
Ruby and Sapphire
Pokémon Pinball
Was often depicted with gloves instead of mittens, as seen in its Red and Blue artwork.
062 Spr 1g 062.png
Spr 2g 062.pngSpr 2s 062.pngSpr 2c 062.png
Spr b 2g 062.pngSpr b 2c 062.png
Spr 3r 062.pngSpr b 3r 062.png
Poliwrath Red and Green
Generation II core series
Ruby and Sapphire
Originally had four fingers on each hand instead of three. This was reflected in its Red and Blue artwork.
063 Spr 1g 063.pngSpr 1b 063.pngSpr b g1 063.png Abra Generation I core series Originally had a segmented tail which lacked the dark ring near its tip, as well as a fused back plate instead of separate shoulder pads.
064 Spr 1g 064.pngSpr b g1 064.png Kadabra Generation I core series Originally had a protrustion on the back of its head, four fingers on each hand instead of three, and lacked the markings on its stomach.
065 Spr 1g 065.png Alakazam Red and Green Originally had a Star of David on its forehead, as well as a fused back plate instead of separate shoulder pads.

Sprite discrepancies due to artist error

Generation I Pokémon

No. Pokémon Game(s) Reason
007 Pinani007.png Squirtle Pokémon Pinball Mistakenly features Wartortle's plastron design.
008 Spr 1b 008.png Wartortle Red and Blue Features a different plastron design than usual.
011 Spr 1y 011.pngSpr b 2g 011.pngSpr b 3r 011.png Metapod Yellow
Generation II core series
Ruby and Sapphire
Emerald
The Yellow front sprite mistakenly has its eyes placed on its back, as seen in artwork for Pokémon the Series. The Generation II back sprite lacks the crest on its back and features an extraneous line connecting the eyes. The crest was added in Ruby and Sapphire, while the line was removed in FireRed and LeafGreen.
017 Spr 2c 017.png Pidgeotto Crystal While properly colored in Gold and Silver, Pidgeotto's beak was recolored to brown, but only on the front sprite.
018 Spr 2g 018.pngSpr 2s 018.pngSpr 2c 018.png Pidgeot Generation II core series Mistakenly features Pidgeotto's tailfeathers, as seen in its Red and Blue artwork.
029 Spr 1b 029.pngSpr b 4d 029.png
Pinani029.png
Nidoran♀ Red and Blue
Diamond and Pearl
Pokémon Pinball
The Red and Blue front sprite lacks a horn. The Diamond and Pearl back sprite has a misshapen inner ear. The Pinball sprite lacks whiskers and has spikes in its ears similar to Nidoran♂.
035 Spr b 2g 035.pngSpr b 2c 035.png
Spr 3r 035.pngSpr 3e 035.pngSpr b 3r 035.png
Spr 4d 035.pngSpr 4p 035.pngSpr b 4d 035.png
Clefairy Generation II core series
Generation III core series
Diamond and Pearl
Platinum
The Generation II and III back sprites mistakenly have Clefable's tail. The Generation III, Diamond, Pearl, and Platinum front sprites have ears with brown undersides instead of black. This was corrected on Platinum's back sprite and from HeartGold and SoulSilver onwards.
036 Spr 1b 036.png Clefable Red and Blue Mistakenly has Clefairy's cheek patterns.
037 Spr 1g 037.pngPinani037.png Vulpix Red and Green
Pokémon Pinball
Has five tails instead of six. Pinball also has two crest curls instead of three. Note that the two curls on the Red and Green sprite are an earlier design and not a mistake.
038 Spr 1y 038.png Ninetales Yellow Has too many tails.
053 Spr 1b 053.png Persian Red and Blue Ears are pointy instead of round.
055 Spr 2c 055.pngSpr b 2c 055.png Golduck Crystal While properly colored in Gold and Silver, Golduck's beak was recolored to light blue.
056 Spr 1b 056.png Mankey Red and Blue Fur is smooth rather than unkempt.
062 Spr b 4d 062.png Poliwrath Diamond and Pearl Missing its intestines.

List of model discrepancies

Model discrepancies due to design revisions

No. Pokémon Game(s) Reason
031 Box XD 031.png Nidoqueen Pokémon Stadium series
Pokémon Colosseum
Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness
Pokémon Battle Revolution
Features fangs, as seen in its Red and Blue artwork.
040 040MSStad.png Wigglytuff Pokémon Stadium series Stomach pattern doesn't reach over its mouth, as seen in its Red and Blue artwork.
062 Box XD 062.png Poliwrath Pokémon Stadium series
Pokémon Colosseum
Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness
Has four fingers on each hand instead of three, as seen in its Red and Blue artwork.
142 Box XD 142.png Aerodactyl Pokémon Stadium series
Pokémon Colosseum
Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness
Pokémon Battle Revolution
Eyes are red instead of green, as seen in its Red and Blue artwork.
144 Box XD 144.pngBox PBR 144.png Articuno Pokémon Stadium series
Pokémon Colosseum
Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness
Pokémon Battle Revolution
Eyes are red instead of brown, as seen in its Generation I artwork. In the Pokémon Stadium series, it also has a blue beak and talons, as seen in its Red and Green artwork.
201 Box XD 201H.png Unown H Pokémon Stadium 2
Pokémon Colosseum
Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness
Pokémon Battle Revolution
Originally was asymmetrical in design.

Model discrepancies due to artist error

No. Pokémon Game(s) Reason
125 125MSStad.png Electabuzz Pokémon Stadium series Has six fingers on each hand.
168 Box PBR 168.png Ariados (Shiny) Pokémon Battle Revolution Completely lacks a Shiny coloration.
191 Box XD 191.png Sunkern Pokémon Stadium 2
Pokémon Colosseum
Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness
Pokémon Battle Revolution
Has green irises.
201 201MSStad.png Unown (Shiny) Pokémon Stadium 2 Completely lacks a Shiny coloration.
207 Box XD 207.png Gligar Pokémon Stadium 2
Pokémon Colosseum
Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness
Pokémon Battle Revolution
Claws are white instead of pink.
208 Box XD 208.png Steelix Pokémon Colosseum
Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness
Pokémon Battle Revolution
Eyes are blue instead of red.
431 Spr 6x 431.png Glameow Generation VI core series Ears are at an incorrect angle. This is notably the only model changed between Generations VI and VII.

References