Talk:Celestica people

Delete proposal

I mentioned this in the discord, but I don't think short stubby articles like this or Ancient hero are helpful. If all known information can be summarized in just a few paragraphs, wouldn't it make more sense to place this information in the articles its relevant in instead of directing users to a different page? -Minibug (talk) 17:10, 4 January 2024 (UTC)

I don't disagree, though I should like to know where you think this info would best be centrally located (if it isn't already there). If that info fits snuggly there, then we can just have this page redirect to that page/section. Landfish7 00:18, 5 January 2024 (UTC)

I don't have a particular problem with this article existing. The best place to cover it otherwise might be on the Sinnoh article? I think it's fine to have a short article, as long as there's something substantial to say about it (which I believe there is in this case) and there isn't another article it could neatly fit into as a section. --SnorlaxMonster 03:23, 5 January 2024 (UTC)

Deletion

Looked through the game script on Poké Corpus to see if I could add references for anything written on this page. As far as I can tell, none of it is directly supported by the text. The Celestica people mentioned in the Old Verses as a people that lived in Hisui in the past whose name was usurped by the Diamond and Pearl Clans, but nothing else is directly attributed to them. If I've missed something, I would appreciate if it's added to the page with a citation. However, since the majority of what's written here is spurious, I believe this page ought to be deleted. --Apopheniac (talk) 18:52, 24 January 2024 (UTC)

In addition to this and the other discussion above, this page isn't necessary at all. It's inconsistent and feels as if it's improperly connected. Anythign considered "substantial" in this situation feels incredibly made up or incorrectly connected. Short articles are fine, but this page doesn't agree with what is said in the game dialogue (or describes it very well, in which the page is low-quality instead). I'd recommend it and the ancient hero page to be removed, and if the someone can actually create a page, then it'd be fine to have it up again. The information here can fit on either Hisui's page or in another page such as "history and legends of Sinnoh" in which we already have multiple of. The information here is just too few, and as much as I don't mind repeat information, this doesn't feel like one of them. TrainerSplash (talk) 09:56, 25 January 2024 (UTC)